[FR]: Prevent webpage shifting when auto-revealing the tab bar in Frameless Mode #2924

Open
opened 2026-11-17 06:43:30 +00:00 by orapie · 0 comments
orapie commented 2026-11-17 06:43:30 +00:00 (Migrated from github.com)

Description

I'd like to request an option to display the auto-hidden tab bar and toolbar as an overlay when using Frameless Mode in macOS fullscreen, without shifting the webpage underneath.

Who's implementing?

The problem

Currently, with Frameless Mode enabled and "Always show the top bar" disabled, moving the cursor to the top of the screen reveals the hidden tab bar and toolbar, but also pushes the entire webpage downward.

When the toolbar disappears, the webpage moves back up.

This repeated vertical movement is distracting and can cause dizziness, especially when frequently switching tabs.

In comparison, Safari and Chrome handle fullscreen toolbar visibility more smoothly, without causing the webpage to jump up and down.

Steps to reproduce

  1. Enable Frameless Mode in Helium.
  2. Make sure "Always show the top bar" is disabled.
  3. Enter macOS fullscreen mode.
  4. Move the cursor to the top of the screen to reveal the hidden tab bar.
  5. Move the cursor away to hide it again.
  6. Observe how the entire webpage moves vertically each time.

Possible solutions

Allow the tab bar and toolbar to appear as an overlay in Frameless Mode, rather than pushing the webpage downward.

Ideally:

  • The webpage should remain completely stationary when the tab bar appears or disappears.
  • The tab bar and toolbar should overlay the webpage without changing its viewport dimensions or scroll position.
  • This behavior could be optional to preserve the current implementation for users who prefer it.

Additional context

A similar behavior was mentioned in #1647, but that issue was closed as a duplicate of a request concerning Safari-style compact tabs.

This request specifically focuses on preventing webpage movement when revealing or hiding the toolbar in Frameless Mode, rather than changing the tab bar's appearance or layout.

Thanks for considering this improvement!

### Description I'd like to request an option to display the auto-hidden tab bar and toolbar as an overlay when using Frameless Mode in macOS fullscreen, without shifting the webpage underneath. ### Who's implementing? - [ ] #2925 ### The problem Currently, with Frameless Mode enabled and "Always show the top bar" disabled, moving the cursor to the top of the screen reveals the hidden tab bar and toolbar, but also pushes the entire webpage downward. When the toolbar disappears, the webpage moves back up. This repeated vertical movement is distracting and can cause dizziness, especially when frequently switching tabs. In comparison, Safari and Chrome handle fullscreen toolbar visibility more smoothly, without causing the webpage to jump up and down. ## Steps to reproduce 1. Enable **Frameless Mode** in Helium. 2. Make sure **"Always show the top bar"** is disabled. 3. Enter macOS fullscreen mode. 4. Move the cursor to the top of the screen to reveal the hidden tab bar. 5. Move the cursor away to hide it again. 6. Observe how the entire webpage moves vertically each time. ### Possible solutions Allow the tab bar and toolbar to appear as an **overlay** in Frameless Mode, rather than pushing the webpage downward. Ideally: - The webpage should remain completely stationary when the tab bar appears or disappears. - The tab bar and toolbar should overlay the webpage without changing its viewport dimensions or scroll position. - This behavior could be optional to preserve the current implementation for users who prefer it. ### Additional context A similar behavior was mentioned in #1647, but that issue was closed as a duplicate of a request concerning Safari-style compact tabs. This request specifically focuses on preventing webpage movement when revealing or hiding the toolbar in Frameless Mode, rather than changing the tab bar's appearance or layout. Thanks for considering this improvement!
Sign in to join this conversation.
No milestone
No assignees
1 participant
Notifications
Due date
The due date is invalid or out of range. Please use the format "yyyy-mm-dd".

No due date set.

Dependencies

No dependencies set.

Reference
imputnet/helium#2924
No description provided.