solidity-lean/SolidCore/Witness/UsingForWiden.lean
Dan Robinson 4ab278c278 #158 USINGFOR-WIDEN-BIND: bind using-for first param by implicit convertibility
`using L for uint8` attaching a library function whose FIRST parameter is WIDER
than the target type was over-rejected. solc separates directive APPLICABILITY
(usingForDirectivesForType: receiver type must EXACTLY equal the directive
target, uint8==uint8 -- left unchanged) from function USABILITY
(Type::attachedFunctions: the receiver need only be IMPLICITLY CONVERTIBLE to
the function's first-parameter type). The model bound the first parameter (and
the re-checked receiver + additional args) with exact-width Ty.matchesShape.

Fix (SolidCore/Solidity/Interface.lean): use DIRECTIONAL
Ty.canImplicitlyConvert in FunctionDecl.firstParamMatchesWithInternalFunctions?
(receiver -> first param) and Parameter.matchesArgWithInternalFunctions?
(re-checked receiver + additional args). Because convertibility is directional,
the WIDER-receiver (uint256 recv, uint8 self), incompatible (uint->bytes32),
and signedness (int8->uint256) cases stay rejected -- confirmed against pinned
solc and preserved in the model.

Ground truth (real solc 0.8.35 / EVM, forge lane using-for-widen):
widenReceiver(255)==256 (uint8 zero-extended, no truncation), widenReceiver(5)
==6, widenAddArg(1000,255)==1255.

- SolidCore/Witness/UsingForWiden.lean: acceptance + 3 runtime witnesses +
  3 over-accept reject guards (all #guard). Imported into SolidCore.lean.
- tests/forge-harness/using-for-widen: src + Forge test + 3 solc-reject guards;
  manifest.json lane (forge + solc_rejects + solc_import + lean evals).

Gate: full `lake build` green (1116 jobs, incl. FuelMonotonicity + all
witnesses); harness --only using-for-widen: solc_rejects=ok forge=ok lean=ok.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
(cherry picked from commit 4e454abb91ea0bb8a386a5f345507324f07f9d45)
2026-07-10 13:34:21 -07:00

250 lines
10 KiB