0
Fork 0
mirror of https://github.com/zeronsh/comet.git synced 2026-11-16 18:57:19 +00:00
comet/docs/research
Daniel Katulevskiy 2500e8b34f
CI: one entry workflow with admission, reuse, priority/locks and a fast pull request tier (#1077)
* CI: one entry workflow with run admission and a fast pull request tier

Pull request checks took a median of ~3 hours from push to done, and ~110
minutes of that was jobs waiting for a runner. Each push asked for ~207
runner-minutes on 15-20 jobs, almost all of it compiling, so bursts of
pushes queued hundreds of jobs and every run held a few runners while the
rest of its jobs waited behind other runs.

- ci.yml is the only pull request / main / merge queue entry point. `plan`
  picks the suites a change needs; `admit` waits until every runner the
  run needs is free, then all its jobs start together and each runner is
  released when its job ends (scripts/ci/admit.py, first come first served
  with conservative backfilling, state read from the Actions API so fork
  pull requests work). `CI result` is the one check to require.
- Pull requests get a fast tier: Windows, macOS, voice and Android run only
  when the change looks platform specific (their files, platform
  conditionals or APIs in changed code); `ci:full` or CI_PR_TIER=full runs
  everything. Main and the merge queue run the full tier.
- Voice: 14 `cargo test` builds capped at 2 jobs (~40 min) become core-tests
  additions plus one nextest build for audio and the mobile voice core; the
  workflow no longer runs uncancelled on every push or saves caches from
  pull requests.
- Windows: three test jobs become one nextest build; one shared cache
  instead of four (~4.5 GB of the 10 GB repository cache).
- Linux UI and browser share one job and cache; edge coordinator and vault
  share one job; the macOS app is built with the test dependencies instead
  of a `cargo check` that recompiled everything; iOS no longer waits for
  the frame-source job, which only runs when the GPUI pin can change.
- Only main saves Rust caches.

* CI admission: cap reservations read from other runs, expire unseen ones

A pull request can edit its own ci.yml, so the reservation in its admit job
name is untrusted. Cap it at the largest plan.py makes, and stop counting an
admitted run's never-created jobs 90 minutes after admission, so one run
cannot hold more than a full run's runners or hold unused ones for long.

* CI: reuse passes on unchanged inputs; ci:priority, ci:lock and an emergency workflow

Reuse. plan fingerprints every suite's inputs in the tree under test (the
merge with main for pull requests): workspace manifest, lockfile, toolchain,
CI files, the suite's workflow and non-Rust files, and for Rust suites the
packages it tests plus every workspace package they depend on, plus any file
outside those that their sources name with a ../ path (scanned every run).
Every job records its pass in the Actions cache under that fingerprint as its
last step; a suite whose jobs all passed is skipped and reserves nothing, and
single Windows and voice jobs are skipped on their own. Pull requests trust
their own passes and main's; main and the merge queue trust only main's;
ci:full and manual runs reuse nothing. Callers are split per suite so each
records under its own fingerprint.

Priority and locks (labels, so triage or above). ci:priority puts a pull
request's runs at the front of the admission queue; ci:lock keeps a full
run's runners out of everyone else's budget while the pull request is open
(until unlabelled, merged, closed or CI_LOCK_HOURS), and admits its runs
first. Runs name their pull request in the admit job; the claim counts only
when that pull request's head is the run's commit. ci-emergency.yml (write
access) locks a pull request, cancels the other pull requests' CI runs and
re-runs its own if needed.

* CI reuse: fail closed

The merge queue, the last gate before main, reuses nothing. A pull request
that changes a Rust build file no selected suite's fingerprint covers reuses
nothing. Sources that build a path from CARGO_MANIFEST_DIR's parent in code
make their suite read the whole workspace. concat!(.., "/../x") paths and
.cargo/ count as inputs.

* CI result: fix the result listing (shell quoting)

* CI: run less on pull requests, more on schedule, and merge tiny test binaries

Measured in CI, test execution is a small part of every job; compiling and
starting jobs that run little is the cost. So:

- Voice: only the audio stack (zeron-audio, which nothing else builds yet)
  and the packaged Windows media runtime remain, for their own files. The
  mobile voice/orb tests were a subset of ios-core, the macOS/Windows
  `cargo check` of harness+engine duplicated the platform builds, and the
  voice-media tests join the Windows nextest build.
- Fast tier gating of jobs and steps to their own files: Windows packaging
  (`app`), the iOS simulator tests and their bindings, the Linux and macOS
  browser/preview fixtures. Android builds the APK on pull requests for the
  app, the FFI crate and dependency changes; the iOS mobile-core paths come
  from zeron-mobile's Cargo closure. Gated jobs and optional steps are part
  of the reuse fingerprint.
- GPUI frame-source runs only when the pinned zui revision moves.
- Version bumps (only `version = "..."` lines in Cargo.toml/Cargo.lock)
  select nothing and are left out of fingerprints.
- nextest `ci` profile for pull requests and main leaves out the slow/soak
  tests (48-chat and real-quantum doc_host sync, the codex dying-server
  backoff, preview leak, two sleep-bound discovery tests); the cursor_shim
  stress test runs 14 rounds (ZERON_STRESS_ROUNDS, 100 by default). Preview
  discovery tests run one at a time (fixed port).
- Nightly ci.yml schedule runs everything in full; weekly-tests.yml runs the
  engine integration binaries and crate tests no workflow ran.
- Linux core no longer builds the 8 test binaries that run nothing there
  (Windows-only or all-#[ignore]d). The small harness, engine and preview
  integration suites move into one `tests/misc` binary per crate. The orb
  geometry tests move to zeron-orb (they tested its re-export); the
  assertion-free microbenchmark is dropped. The macOS app builds with the
  tests instead of rebuilding zeron-ui without the fixture feature.

* CI: pass the nextest config to the build-only steps too

NEXTEST_PROFILE=ci names a profile from scripts/ci/nextest.toml; the macOS and
Windows `--no-run` builds did not load that file, so nextest refused the
unknown profile.

* Engine: keep the git identity setup inside the home it is given

configure_git_identity pinned HOME but inherited XDG_CONFIG_HOME, and
`git config --global` writes $XDG_CONFIG_HOME/git/config when that file
exists. With a sandbox or test home, the identity landed in the developer's
real git config: running the engine tests on a machine with XDG_CONFIG_HOME
set replaced the user's name and email with the test's. An XDG_CONFIG_HOME
outside the given home now gives way to the home's own, and the test pins it
for its own git calls too.

* CI: iOS simulator tests in parallel with ios-core; Windows UI tests side by side

- The C header and module map the simulator tests link are committed in
  apps/ios/CoreFFI (outside Xcode's synchronized folders) and refreshed by
  scripts/ios/build-core.sh like the Swift bindings; ios-core checks all
  three are current. ios-tests no longer waits for ios-core's artifact, so
  the iOS path is one job long instead of two.
- The simulator core for the unit tests builds in the dev profile, not the
  optimized `mobile` profile the app ships.
- Windows runs zeron-ui's tests side by side: nextest gives each its own
  process, so the in-process `--test-threads=1` restriction no longer applies.

* CI admission: budget defaults at the organization's runner limits

20 jobs in total and 5 on macOS (the organization's concurrency limits), and
at most 10 on Windows so Linux keeps half the pool. The repository variables
still override them.

* CI: skip the browser steps when the Linux setup failed

They run after a failed UI test on purpose (a separate signal), but without
the system packages (an apt mirror stall) they can only fail too.

* CI: retry the WebRTC terminal path test (a known race)

remote_terminals' network-change test asserts no keystroke goes through the
relay once the path reports Direct; in a loaded run one did. Retried like the
other timing-sensitive tests in nextest.toml until the race is fixed.

* Fix two races that failed CI on loaded runners

- Muse: a crash usually shows first as "Muse stdout closed", racing the
  process exit; `try_wait` lost that race under load and users got the bare
  protocol error instead of "Muse exited unexpectedly" with Muse's last
  stderr lines. Wait up to 250 ms for the exit, as the Pi driver already
  does (a_crash_mid_turn_reports_muses_last_words failed this way).
- Remote terminals: a subscription reported TerminalPath::Direct before
  attaching the direct writer, so a keystroke typed by whoever saw Direct
  could still go through the relay (a_terminal_rides_a_real_webrtc_pair_
  through_a_network_change failed this way). Report Direct once writes
  ride the link. The CI retry for that test goes.

Both tests pass 25 runs in a row under CPU load.

* CI reuse: count only the CI files a suite runs

Every suite's fingerprint included all of scripts/ci and the composite
actions, so a change to the planner or the scheduler (which decide what runs,
not whether it passes) re-ran every suite. Each suite now counts the CI files
it executes: nextest.toml and the Linux or Windows setup for the Rust suites,
test-core.sh for core, the macOS fixture runner for macOS, apt-install.sh for
the installer. ci.yml still counts for all.

* docs: changing the fingerprint inputs reruns everything once

* CI admission: no circular waits

Two ways admission could deadlock (until the fail-open timeout):

- Each waiting run counted every other waiting run's admit job as a busy
  runner, including runs queued behind it. With a full run (16 of 20) at the
  head and five or more waiting behind it, the head waited for their runners
  and they waited for it. A run now counts only the admit runners ahead of it.
- Two ci:lock labels each reserved 16 of 20 runners and counted the other's
  reservation, so neither locked pull request (nor anyone else) could start.
  Locks are now ordered by when their label was added: an older lock ignores
  a newer one's standing reservation.

Every wait now points forward in one order, so no cycle can form. A test
simulates 3000 random queues (sizes, priority, overlapping locks, polling
order) and checks they all drain; the previous scheduler deadlocked in 309.
The fail-open timeout drops from 5 h to 2 h as the backstop for the one case
outside the model (waiting admit jobs taking every runner in the pool).

* CI admission: waiting admit jobs yield when they starve the pool; ignore runs that never take their turn

Waiting costs a hosted runner from the same pool as the suites. With about
20 runs waiting, their admit jobs held the whole pool, admitted runs' jobs
got no runner, and nothing moved until the 2-hour fail-open. When an
admitted run's Linux or Windows job has queued 10 minutes, every running
admit job but the first quarter of the budget now starts its run without a
reservation, giving its runner back. A new test models GitHub's runner pool
as well as admission: without yielding most 30-run queues never drain, with
it all 200 do.

A reservation read from another run is not trusted, but a run whose edited
admit step never finished still held everyone behind it for 2 hours (and a
fake admitted run held a full run for 90 minutes). A waiting run that could
have been admitted for 3 minutes but still waits is now ignored, and an
admitted run's jobs that have not appeared 10 minutes after admission stop
counting, except the late result and publish jobs.

Polling backs off further from the head of the queue (5 min, 10 min under
400 requests left): the GITHUB_TOKEN quota is shared with releases, the
Cursor SDK update and CI emergency.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Co-authored-by: zeronsh[bot] <346184242+zeronsh[bot]@users.noreply.github.com>

* CI: voice and the Linux browser fixture nightly only; forks reuse only main's passes

Over two weeks the voice jobs left after the move into core-tests (AEC3
and the packaged Windows runtime) never failed, and the Linux browser
fixture's failures were window-timing flakes and package downloads. Both now
run nightly, on manual runs and with ci:full. The zeron-ui tests stay on
every change: 2,046 tests in 29 s, and the only check that caught one real
regression in that window.

A fork's earlier runs could save a pass entry for the fingerprint of a
later, clean-looking commit, so its suites would be skipped and the pull
request would still show a green CI result. Until the merge queue (which
reuses nothing) is the required gate, forks reuse only main's passes;
CI_FORK_REUSE=own turns their own back on (ci.yml passes it to plan in the
workflow commit that follows).

Docs: admission's new yield and unresponsive-run rules and polling.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Co-authored-by: zeronsh[bot] <346184242+zeronsh[bot]@users.noreply.github.com>

* Engine: keep the user's own XDG_CONFIG_HOME when the git identity home is theirs

The XDG_CONFIG_HOME guard replaced any XDG_CONFIG_HOME outside `home` with
`home`'s. When `home` is this process's own, that hid an identity the user
keeps in an XDG_CONFIG_HOME elsewhere, and the machine identity went into
~/.gitconfig, which wins over it. It now only applies to a sandbox or test
home.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Co-authored-by: zeronsh[bot] <346184242+zeronsh[bot]@users.noreply.github.com>

* CI workflows: Android gets only its own secrets, on pushes to main; CI_FORK_REUSE

secrets: inherit gave android.yml every repository secret, and the merge
queue (code not on main yet) would have signed with the release keystore.
ci.yml now passes the four signing secrets and the R2 token by name, on
pushes to main only; pull requests and the merge queue use the debug key,
as forks always did.

Also: ci.yml passes the CI_FORK_REUSE variable to plan, and the comments in
ci.yml, voice-tests.yml and ui-tests.yml say voice and the Linux browser
fixture run nightly.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>

* CI: test-core also runs main's crates/doc/tests (attachments_roundtrip is among them)

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>

---------

Co-authored-by: Wing <44917547+wingleeio@users.noreply.github.com>
Co-authored-by: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Co-authored-by: zeronsh[bot] <346184242+zeronsh[bot]@users.noreply.github.com>
History 2026-11-01 15:51:25 -07:00
..
cursor-auth-incident ci(cursor): automate SDK updates and gate releases on auth compatibility 2026-09-18 19:14:09 +00:00
cursor-stability test(cursor): stress steering bursts and prioritize cancellation 2026-09-18 02:36:41 +00:00
cursor-steering-stability Preserve Cursor user context through steering and startup interruption 2026-09-18 20:02:53 +00:00
acp.md Replace Pi ACP adapter with native RPC integration (#630) 2026-09-29 17:14:54 -07:00
appshots.md Add desktop Appshots with queue-safe delivery and iOS presentation (#216) 2026-09-12 17:11:25 -07:00
codex-subagents.md CI: one entry workflow with admission, reuse, priority/locks and a fast pull request tier (#1077) 2026-11-01 15:51:25 -07:00
codex-voice-ios.md Internal session plumbing and packaging cleanup (#819) 2026-10-06 23:47:32 -07:00
codex-voice-remote.md Internal session plumbing and packaging cleanup (#819) 2026-10-06 23:47:32 -07:00
codex-voice.md Internal session plumbing and packaging cleanup (#819) 2026-10-06 23:47:32 -07:00
diri-sidebar-browser-plan.md Persist embedded browser sessions across tabs and app restarts (#573) 2026-10-12 17:53:46 -07:00
durable-objects-language.md rename: comet -> zeron everywhere (binary, crates, env, data dir, iOS) 2026-08-14 10:49:19 +00:00
feature-inventory.md Zeron Cloud, provider switching, and the phone model picker (#966) 2026-10-22 03:18:13 -07:00
gpui.md Foundation: architecture, research, Rust workspace scaffold, TS edge port 2026-07-19 18:04:51 +00:00
harness.md rename: comet -> zeron everywhere (binary, crates, env, data dir, iOS) 2026-08-14 10:49:19 +00:00
loro-rust.md rename: comet -> zeron everywhere (binary, crates, env, data dir, iOS) 2026-08-14 10:49:19 +00:00
model-catalog-validation.md docs(models): record full validation and live discovery results 2026-09-21 09:15:19 +00:00
model-discovery-reliability.md fix(cursor): recover abandoned runs and stabilize model discovery 2026-09-18 01:20:28 +00:00
mugen-pretext.md rename: comet -> zeron everywhere (binary, crates, env, data dir, iOS) 2026-08-14 10:49:19 +00:00
pi-rpc.md Replace Pi ACP adapter with native RPC integration (#630) 2026-09-29 17:14:54 -07:00
sidebar-view-options.md fix: address sidebar view options review 2026-08-23 19:34:42 +02:00
voice-remote-testing.md Internal session plumbing and packaging cleanup (#819) 2026-10-06 23:47:32 -07:00
windows-click-drag-audit.md Add file tree context actions and drag-and-drop moves (#514) 2026-09-30 20:13:10 -07:00